Need help now? Support now: crisis lines by country.

Questions about pain · Mathematical Institute for Research of Pain

If expectations can change pain, does that mean the pain is imagined?

No. An expectation effect is a change in real experience. Showing that one exists is not evidence that pain or relief is made up.

A person’s report of an experience as pain should be respected.

International Association for the Study of Pain, revised definition of pain (2020), the fourth of its six notes. Published in S. N. Raja and others, Pain 161 (2020): 1976–1982 · Source

The short answer

Expectations can change how much something hurts and how much a treatment helps. When that finding is turned into “so the pain was never real”, the conclusion goes further than the evidence. The Institute’s Pain Bias Codex names this step “Expectation means the pain is unreal”. Context-sensitive pain is still pain.

What is known

Bingel and colleagues (2011) gave healthy volunteers the same infusion of the opioid remifentanil while heat pain was applied, and changed only what they were led to expect: no pain relief, pain relief, or pain getting worse because the drug had been stopped. Positive expectations doubled the pain relief people reported, and negative expectations abolished it. The drug and the dose did not change between conditions. The experiment shows a real change in experience, produced by context.

What is not yet known

This was an acute experiment in healthy volunteers. It does not identify the cause of anyone’s chronic pain, and it does not explain all chronic pain. It also says nothing about how often people are accused of imagining their pain.

What would tell us

The same kind of experiment, repeated in people who live with chronic pain and over longer periods, would show how far the effect reaches and how large it is there.

A worked example

Write YY for the pain a person reports and EE for what they were led to expect. The experiment shows that the distribution of YY depends on EE while the drug is held fixed. That is a statement about what changes pain. It is not a statement about whether YY is real: a quantity that responds to its conditions is as real as one that does not.

The fair use of the finding is to treat expectation as one possible influence on real experience, not as a test of whether someone is telling the truth. Nothing in it asks the person in pain to think differently.

These pages explain reasoning and evidence. Nothing here is medical advice or a forecast about any person.

Sources

  1. Bingel U, Wanigasekera V, Wiech K, et al. The effect of treatment expectation on drug efficacy: imaging the analgesic benefit of the opioid remifentanil. Sci Transl Med. 2011;3(70):70ra14. doi:10.1126/scitranslmed.3001244
  2. Raja SN, Carr DB, Cohen M, et al. The revised International Association for the Study of Pain definition of pain: concepts, challenges, and compromises. Pain. 2020;161(9):1976–1982. doi:10.1097/j.pain.0000000000001939

Pain words: Placebo · Nocebo · Descending inhibition · Conditioned pain modulation · All words

Related, in Nociflux, the Institute’s ecosystem for living with pain: the N-of-1 Lab.

Inside the Institute

The Pain Bias Codex gathers checks on conclusions about pain, in four families. With an invite code you can read this check there beside the others, with its full evidence notes. Pain math explains what the Institute does.

No code yet? Ask for an invite. A person reads every request and writes back by hand with an invite code, so it may take a few days.

Need help now? Support now: crisis lines by country.

Except where a page says otherwise, the Institute’s own text and figures are shared under CC BY-NC 4.0. Pictures and quotations from others keep their own credits and licences.

Back to the invite page · Sign in

Paper